Sign Up for Discounts
This form does not yet contain any fields.
    Follow us on Facebook
    Controller Library Value Pack
    CFO Library Value Pack
    Accounting Standards Library
    Sunday
    Jan062013

    What is substance over form?

    Substance over form is the concept that the information shown in the financial statements and accompanying disclosures of a business should reflect the underlying realities of accounting transactions, rather than the legal form in which they appear.

    The key point of the concept is that a transaction should not be recorded in such a manner as to hide the true intent of the transaction, which would mislead the readers of a company's financial statements.

    Substance over form is a particular concern under Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), since GAAP is largely rules-based, and so creates specific hurdles that must be achieved in order to record a transaction in a certain way. Thus, someone intent on hiding the true intent of a transaction could structure it to just barely meet GAAP rules, which would allow that person to record the transaction in a manner that hides its true intent. Conversely, International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) are more principles-based, so it is more difficult for someone to justifiably hide the intent of a transaction if they are using the IFRS framework.

    Thus far, the substance over form argument assumes that someone is attempting to deliberately hide the true intent of a transaction - but it may also arise simply because a transaction is extremely complex, which makes it quite difficult to ascertain what the substance of the transaction is - even for a law-abiding accountant.

    Examples of substance over form issues are:

    • Company A is essentially an agent for Company B, and so should only record a sale on behalf of Company B in the amount of the related commission. However, Company A wants its sales to appear larger, so it records the entire amount of a sale as revenue.
    • Company C hides debt liabilities in related entities, so that the debt does not appear on its balance sheet.
    • Company D creates bill and hold paperwork to legitimize the sale of goods to customers where the goods have not yet left the premises of Company D.

    Outside auditors are continually examining the transactions of their clients to ensure that the substance over form criterion is being followed. The issue is of some importance to auditors, since they are being asked to attest to the fairness of presentation of a set of financial statements, and fairness of presentation and the substance over form concept are essentially the same thing.

    Related Topics

    Accrual principle
    Conservatism principle
    Consistency principle
    Cost principle
    Economic entity principle
    Full disclosure principle
    Matching principle
    Materiality principle
    Monetary unit principle
    Reliability principle
    Revenue recognition principle
    Time period principle
    What is a going concern qualification?
    What is the prudence concept in accounting?

    PrintView Printer Friendly Version

    EmailEmail Article to Friend

    Reader Comments

    There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
    Editor Permission Required
    You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.