What is Cookie Jar Accounting?

Cookie jar accounting occurs when a business sets up excessive reserves in profitable periods and draws down these reserves during lower-profit periods. The intent is to give the impression that the organization generates more consistent results than is really the case. When investors believe that a firm is able to consistently meet its earnings targets, they tend to place a higher value on its stock, which may be substantially higher than it is actually worth. Conversely, a business with variable results that does not use cookie jar accounting will report periods of large gains and large losses, which tends to drive away investors. Thus, a business that uses cookie jar accounting may be considered more valuable than a business that does not.

There is a greater temptation to use cookie jar accounting among publicly held businesses, since doing so can mislead analysts into issuing more favorable reports about them to the investment community. This approach to reporting earnings does not reflect actual results, and so can be considered fraudulent reporting.

Cookie jar reserves can be created either by over-estimating the more common reserves (such as for bad debts) or by taking large one-time charges for expected losses from one-time events, such as acquisitions or downsizings.

Example of Cookie Jar Accounting

Milagro Corporation has just gone public, and its CFO wants to report a consistent, gradual increase in profits to the investment community. In its first quarter of public reporting, a large sale generates $10 million of profits. Rather than reporting the full amount at once, the CFO greatly increases the company’s reserves for bad debts and obsolete inventory, and then draws them down over the next few quarters in order to report a modest quarterly profit increase in each successive quarter.

Related AccountingTools Courses

Fraud Examination

Fraud Schemes

How to Audit for Fraud

FAQs

Where did the cookie jar accounting concept come from?

The cookie jar accounting concept emerged in the 1980s and 1990s as regulators and analysts criticized companies for manipulating reserves to smooth earnings. The term gained prominence through enforcement actions by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, which publicly challenged the practice of overstating liabilities and later reversing them to inflate income.

What financial statement patterns may signal cookie jar accounting?

Potential warning signs include unusually large reserve increases during highly profitable periods, followed by material reserve reversals when earnings decline. Other indicators include inconsistent estimation methodologies, declining reserve balances without corresponding reductions in underlying risk, and improved margins that appear driven by reserve releases rather than operational performance.